Analysis
What Alberta's Heritage Fund means for Newfoundland and Labrador's Future Fund
Alberta started saving 30% of its oil money in 1976, stopped by 1987, and spent most of what the fund earned. Newfoundland and Labrador's Future Fund is at the same fork now that yearly contributions are no longer required, and Alberta's record shows which way the money tends to go.
Alberta started like Norway, before Norway
Alberta set up the Heritage Savings Trust Fund in 1976 to hold back part of its oil and gas revenue. The rule at the start was simple: 30% of non-renewable resource revenue went into the fund. That share was cut to 15% in 1982-83, and resource revenue stopped flowing in after 1986-87. (Alberta Heritage Fund annual report 2023-24 (opens in a new tab)) Norway's fund wasn't set up until 1990 and got its first transfer in 1996. (Norwegian Petroleum (opens in a new tab))
So Alberta had a head start of two decades. What it did next is the part worth studying.
Where Alberta's oil money went
The province's own historical summary, covering May 1976 to March 2024, tells the story in four numbers. About $12.0 billion of resource revenue went in. About $42.0 billion of investment income came out to the general revenue fund, where it paid for ordinary government spending. Another $3.5 billion was spent on capital projects. At the end, the fund held $22.9 billion. (Alberta Heritage Fund annual report 2023-24 (opens in a new tab))
- Resource revenue put in$12B
- Income moved to general spending$42B
- Spent on capital projects$3.5B
- Fund value, March 2024$22.9B
Source: Alberta Heritage Savings Trust Fund annual report 2023-24 (opens in a new tab), historical summary.
Put another way, the fund sent about three and a half times as much income to general spending as it ever received in resource revenue. Only about $7.0 billion of its income was kept in the fund over those 48 years. There were short bursts of saving: $3.9 billion of deposits between 2005-06 and 2007-08, then none until $753 million in 2022-23. (Alberta Heritage Fund annual report 2023-24 (opens in a new tab))
Alberta's reset
Alberta has changed course in the last few years. A 2022-23 change to the law keeps the fund's income in the fund unless Treasury Board approves a withdrawal. The province deposited $2.8 billion from its 2024-25 surplus, the fund returned 8.0% in 2025-26, and it reached $32.0 billion on March 31, 2026. A new arm's-length corporation now oversees it, and the stated goal is $250 billion by 2050. (Government of Alberta (opens in a new tab))
The test came quickly. Alberta's Budget 2026 assumed oil at US$60.50 a barrel and projected a $9.4 billion deficit, with deficits for the two years after. Each $1 drop in oil was worth about $680 million to the bottom line. (Global News (opens in a new tab)) Net financial debt was projected at $51.4 billion for 2026-27. (TD Economics (opens in a new tab)) When prices jumped later in the year, the first-quarter update swung to a forecast surplus of about $2 billion, with royalties expected near $23 billion, roughly a quarter of provincial revenue. (The Hub (opens in a new tab)) The budget still shows the province riding the oil price, fund or no fund.
What this meant for workers
A savings fund doesn't keep anyone on a rig. When oil crashed in 2014, about 43,000 Albertans lost oil and gas jobs by spring 2016, by Statistics Canada's Labour Force Survey count. (CBC News (opens in a new tab)) The Heritage Fund didn't change that.
Where a fund matters is the second hit. Newfoundland and Labrador went into the same crash with no savings. Its April 2016 budget raised the HST to 15%, added 16.5 cents a litre to gas tax, brought in a temporary levy of up to $900 per taxpayer and cut about 650 public-sector jobs, facing a deficit near $2 billion. (National Observer (opens in a new tab)) Workers who had just lost offshore or trades work paid more tax at the same time. A fund that can carry the budget through a bad year takes some of that second hit away.
Three funds side by side
| Norway | Alberta | Newfoundland and Labrador | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Started | 1990 (first transfer 1996) | 1976 | 2023 |
| Value | About NOK 21,300 billion (end of 2025) | $32.0 billion (March 31, 2026) | $524.7 million (December 31, 2025) |
| Per person | About NOK 3.8 million | About $6,270 | About $950 |
| What goes in | The state's net oil cash flow, every year | 30% of resource revenue at first, then nothing after 1986-87; surplus deposits since 2022-23 | A portion of royalties and asset sales; yearly contributions no longer required since 2026 |
| What can come out | About the expected real return, 3% a year | Income, with Treasury Board approval | Nothing until 2033 or until it covers 10 years of debt maturities, then set purposes |
What it means for Newfoundland and Labrador
Newfoundland and Labrador's Future Fund is three years old. It holds $524.7 million, of which $467.9 million was paid in, and earned an annualized 7.36% in the nine months to December 31, 2025, against a 3.80% average cost on the province's new borrowing that year. Withdrawals are blocked until 10 years after March 30, 2023, or until the fund covers 10 years of unfunded debt maturities, and the allowed uses include debt payments and the cost of abandoning and decommissioning offshore oil projects. (Government of Newfoundland and Labrador (opens in a new tab))
In May 2026 the House of Assembly passed changes that remove the requirement for yearly contributions and tighten withdrawals, so the money is kept for debt and long-term liabilities. (Government of Newfoundland and Labrador (opens in a new tab)) The 2026-27 budget then put nothing in, after $108.8 million the year before, while forecasting $2.03 billion in offshore royalties, a $688.5 million deficit and net debt of $20.8 billion. (Budget 2026 Statements and Schedules (opens in a new tab)) That works out to about $37,700 of net debt per resident. (Statistics Canada (opens in a new tab))
This is where Alberta's history lines up. Alberta also stopped saving when budgets got tight, and it also kept the fund but spent what it earned. The difference is that Newfoundland and Labrador now limits what can come out, and Alberta, for most of its history, didn't. The risk is on the way in, not the way out.
The scale is different too. Offshore royalties paid for about 18% of provincial revenue in 2024-25 and peaked at $3.2 billion in 2011. (CAPP (opens in a new tab)) For a sense of size, 30% of this year's budgeted offshore royalties, Alberta's original rule, would be about $609 million: more than the whole Future Fund holds today. Bay du Nord could add up to $6.4 billion in direct provincial revenue in its first phase, with first oil expected in 2031. (Government of Newfoundland and Labrador (opens in a new tab)) That is the next windfall the province will have to decide about.
For a worker, two things follow. The province's ability to cover end-of-life costs on offshore fields, through the fund or otherwise, bears on decommissioning work that trades here will do in the 2030s and beyond. And when the next downturn comes, a province with savings is less likely to raise taxes and cut services in the same year offshore crews are laid off. Keep your tickets current with training, look at funding for courses, and see offshore jobs open now and what each role pays.
Our view: the case for paying down debt first is real when the province owes about $37,700 per resident. But Alberta shows what happens when saving is a yearly choice: the choice is always no in a bad year, and good years are spent too. A fixed share of new royalties, set in law, would be a better guard than a fund that only gets money when there is money left over. It could go to the Future Fund or straight to debt; what matters is that the rule is set before the money arrives. Bay du Nord gives the province a clean chance to set that rule now, years before first oil.
Worth copying
- Alberta's 2022-23 change that keeps fund income in the fund unless Treasury Board approves: earnings that stay compound.
- An arm's-length board and a public target, like Alberta's $250 billion by 2050, so progress can be measured.
- Norway's spending rule: take out about the expected real return, around 3% a year, and leave the capital alone.
Worth avoiding
- Saving only in good years: Alberta's 30% rule became 15% in 1982-83 and stopped after 1986-87.
- Spending the fund's earnings as they arrive: Alberta moved $42.0 billion of income to general spending against $12.0 billion put in.
- Assuming a fund protects jobs: about 43,000 Albertans lost oil and gas jobs in the 2014-16 crash, fund or not.
Sources
- Government of Alberta: Heritage Savings Trust Fund (opens in a new tab) Values as of March 31, 2026.
- Alberta Heritage Savings Trust Fund annual report 2023-24 (opens in a new tab) Historical summary, May 19, 1976 to March 31, 2024.
- Global News: Alberta budget 2026 (opens in a new tab) February 26, 2026.
- TD Economics: Alberta Budget 2026 (opens in a new tab) February 26, 2026.
- The Hub: Five things to know from Alberta's first quarter fiscal update (opens in a new tab) September 7, 2026.
- Norwegian Petroleum: Management of revenues (opens in a new tab)
- Government of Newfoundland and Labrador: Future Fund (opens in a new tab) Value as of December 31, 2025.
- Government of Newfoundland and Labrador: Legislation to amend the Future Fund Act passes third reading (opens in a new tab) May 5, 2026.
- Government of Newfoundland and Labrador: Budget 2026 Statements and Schedules (opens in a new tab)
- Statistics Canada: Canada's population estimates, second quarter 2026 (opens in a new tab) Population on July 1, 2026.
- CAPP: Canada's Offshore Oil and Gas Industry (opens in a new tab) April 17, 2026. CAPP is the oil industry's association.
- CBC News: Just how many jobs have been cut in the oilpatch? (opens in a new tab) 2016.
- National Observer: Newfoundland and Labrador budget delivers tax hikes, job cuts, $2B deficit (opens in a new tab) April 14, 2016.
- Government of Newfoundland and Labrador: Bay du Nord benefits agreement (opens in a new tab) March 3, 2026.
Written with AI tools from the public sources listed above. Spot an error? Email info@bdnsupplierdirectory.ca and we'll fix it.