BDN home Get job alerts

Analysis

What Brazil's local content rules would mean for Newfoundland and Labrador's offshore workers

Probably fewer steady jobs than they promise. Brazil's buy-local quotas helped build a shipyard workforce of over 82,000, then lost almost half of it in two years when the orders dried up, and the quotas were cut roughly in half in 2017. NL's first-consideration rules and negotiated deals like Bay du Nord's are a better fit, as long as the commitments are checked.

What Brazil tried

Brazil wrote buy-local rules straight into its oil licences. Fixed minimum percentages of Brazilian goods and services arrived with the fifth licensing round in 2003, and both the requirements and the fines for missing them rose sharply in the rounds that followed. (Wood Mackenzie (opens in a new tab)) Until 2017, the share a company promised to buy at home was also scored when blocks were auctioned, so bidders competed partly on who would promise the most. (Columbia Center on Sustainable Investment (opens in a new tab))

The goal was to turn the huge pre-salt discoveries into a home-grown shipbuilding and supply industry. For a few years, the jobs came. Brazil's shipyards employed 82,472 people in 2014, by the count of Sinaval, the shipbuilders' association. (BNamericas (opens in a new tab))

Where it broke

Then the orders stopped. Between 2014 and 2016, shipbuilding lost 49% of its workforce, about 30,000 jobs, according to Brazil's statistics agency. In Rio de Janeiro, employment fell from 31,200 to 8,000, almost three jobs in four. The agency said the industry had been driven mainly by ships and floating platforms for oil. (IBGE (opens in a new tab)) The collapse in oil prices and the 2015 Lava Jato corruption investigation, which hit Petrobras, are the main causes cited. (BNamericas (opens in a new tab)) At the bottom, fewer than 15,000 shipyard jobs were left, down more than 80%. (Datamar News (opens in a new tab))

The quotas were part of the problem, not just the price crash. A 2015 Oxford Energy Forum paper found local content promises were a serious risk for projects because they were locked in years before anything was bought, which raised the risk of cost overruns, delays and poor quality. (Oxford Energy Forum (opens in a new tab)) Companies that fell short asked the regulator for waivers or faced fines, and one stated aim of the 2017 reset was to cut the flood of waiver requests. (Tozzini Freire (opens in a new tab)) An OECD study modelling Brazil's rules found large long-term gains from relaxing them, despite early losses in shipbuilding. (OECD (opens in a new tab))

The 2017 reset

In April 2017 Brazil's energy policy council set new minimums for offshore blocks: 18% for exploration, 25% for well construction, 40% for subsea collection and flow lines, and 25% for production platforms. Onshore blocks stayed at 50%. (CNPE Resolution 7/2017 (opens in a new tab)) UNCTAD described the change as cutting the requirement about in half. (UNCTAD (opens in a new tab)) From the 14th round on, local content stopped counting toward who wins a block. (Columbia Center on Sustainable Investment (opens in a new tab))

In 2018, companies with older contracts were allowed to swap their commitments for the new, lower ones with smaller fines. Wood Mackenzie estimated that under the old rules only 26 floating production ships (FPSOs) would be working by 2030, while the new rules could get all 36 needed by 2027, with hulls built in Asia and selected modules built in Brazil. It also forecast over 95,000 extra jobs over a decade. Those were forecasts, not results. (Wood Mackenzie (opens in a new tab))

Production did take off. Brazil pumped a record 3.77 million barrels of oil a day in 2025, up 12.3% in a year, with about 79.6% from the pre-salt. (Agencia iNFRA (opens in a new tab)) The regulator, ANP, counts around 15 FPSO projects under way or expected and says Brazil accounts for about a third of global FPSO demand. But most of that work is done abroad. Petrobras's P-78, which sailed in 2025, had its topside modules built in Singapore, China and Brazil, and was integrated in Singapore. (World Oil (opens in a new tab)) ANP's own certificates show how much stayed in Brazil, and its presentation notes the offshore average is "less than half of onshore". (ANP (opens in a new tab))

Brazilian content certified on six FPSOs, 2018 to 2024% local content
  • Campos dos Goytacazes (2018)34%
  • Carioca (2021)18.8%
  • Guanabara (2022)12.4%
  • Sepetiba (2023)22.7%
  • Almirante Barroso (2023)26.2%
  • Marechal Duque de Caxias (2024)11.8%

Source: ANP, FPSO Brazil Congress 2026 (opens in a new tab). Five are converted tankers; Sepetiba is a new build.

The certificates also show where Brazilian yards win. Modules built in Brazil averaged 92% local content for flare systems, 89% for gas processing and 74% for oil processing. (ANP (opens in a new tab)) The yards compete on specific packages, not whole ships. And the rules still have teeth: if a company delivers less than 65% of its minimum, it pays a fine of 40% of the shortfall, rising toward 75% for bigger misses. (Columbia Center on Sustainable Investment (opens in a new tab))

Brazil is pushing local work again, by other means

Since 2024 Brazil has leaned on incentives rather than auction scores. Shipyard jobs climbed to 32,425 by the end of September 2024, up 24% from the end of 2023, on orders from Petrobras and its shipping arm Transpetro. (BNamericas (opens in a new tab)) New rules tie faster tax write-offs to building vessels at home: at least 50% Brazilian content for tankers over 15,000 tonnes and 60% for smaller support vessels. (Datamar News (opens in a new tab)) A 2025 decree cuts royalties on some older fields in return for buying in Brazil; ANP estimates about US$2 billion of local supply across at least three production units. (ANP (opens in a new tab)) Rystad Energy reports that Petrobras now asks for local construction even on projects with no contractual requirement. (OilNOW (opens in a new tab))

Newfoundland and Labrador, side by side

How Brazil and Newfoundland and Labrador try to keep offshore work at home
BrazilNewfoundland and Labrador
Oil production3.77 million barrels a day (2025)About 240,000 barrels a day (2025)
How local work is requiredFixed minimum percentages in each licence, with finesFirst consideration where competitive on price, quality and delivery; no fixed percentages
Offshore minimums18% exploration, 25% wells, 40% subsea lines, 25% platforms (2017 rules)Negotiated project by project, such as 95% of Bay du Nord subsea fabrication
Workforce swingShipbuilding jobs down 49% from 2014 to 2016Direct oil and gas jobs down from about 15,600 (2014) to just over 6,000 (2024)
Newer toolsRoyalty cuts and tax write-offs in return for local work$200 million fabrication fund and an equity option of up to 10% at Bay du Nord
Source: Agencia iNFRA (opens in a new tab), CAPP (opens in a new tab), CNPE (opens in a new tab), IBGE (opens in a new tab), C-NLOER (opens in a new tab), Government of Newfoundland and Labrador (opens in a new tab), Datamar News (opens in a new tab).

NL never had Brazil's quotas. Every offshore benefits plan here must give first consideration to services from the province and goods made here, but only where they are competitive on fair market price, quality and delivery. (C-NLOER (opens in a new tab)) Qualified residents get first consideration for training and jobs on each project. (C-NLOER (opens in a new tab)) The hard numbers come from negotiation instead. For how a quota law plays out in a newer industry, see our Guyana comparison.

What it means for Newfoundland and Labrador

Scale is where the comparison breaks down first. NL produced about 240,000 barrels a day in 2025, down 35% from its 2007 peak. (CAPP (opens in a new tab)) Brazil pumped more than 15 times as much in 2025, and even it couldn't keep its yards busy through the 2014 to 2016 downturn. A quota only works if there is a steady line of orders to fill it. NL builds one big project at a time, and direct oil and gas jobs here fell from about 15,600 in 2014 to just over 6,000 in 2024 as construction wound down. (CAPP (opens in a new tab)) A Brazilian-style percentage wouldn't have changed that.

Bay du Nord's deal looks more like Brazil's new approach than its old one. The province negotiated specific commitments: at least 95% of subsea fabrication in the province, at least 3 million hours of fabrication work, apprenticeship targets of 10% in construction and 15% in onshore operations, and a $200 million fund for a floating dry dock at Bull Arm, alongside an option to own up to 10% of the project. (Government of Newfoundland and Labrador (opens in a new tab)) Brazil's 2025 royalty cut is the same kind of trade: give up some government take to get the work done at home.

For a welder, pipefitter or fabricator, Brazil's story is the one to remember. Jobs created by a quota last as long as the order book. Brazil's yards lost almost half their workforce in two years. The trades and tickets that move between oil, marine, shipbuilding and other heavy industry are what carried people through. Check what training you need, see what funding can pay for it, and look at offshore jobs open now or what each role pays.

Our view: NL shouldn't copy hard percentage quotas. Brazil's own record shows targets set above what local yards could deliver on price and schedule led to waivers, fines and delay risk, and the jobs still left with the orders. What is worth copying is the 2017 honesty (realistic numbers that are actually enforced) and the habit of certifying what was really built at home. NL could publish a checked local share for each project's major packages, the way ANP publishes FPSO certificates, so promises like Bay du Nord's can be measured against what gets built.

Worth copying

  • Set minimums local firms can actually meet, and enforce them: Brazil's 2017 offshore minimums of 18% to 40% replaced targets companies kept asking to waive.
  • Certify and publish what was really built at home: ANP's six FPSO certificates ranged from 11.8% to 34%.
  • Aim at the packages local yards can win: Brazilian-built flare modules averaged 92% local content and gas processing modules 89%.
  • Trade incentives for local work where the numbers add up, as Brazil's 2025 royalty cut does for about US$2 billion of local supply.

Worth avoiding

  • Scoring licence bids on buy-local promises made years before anything is bought: Brazil dropped this from its 14th round.
  • Building a trade workforce around one buyer's orders: Brazil's shipbuilding lost 49% of its jobs from 2014 to 2016.
  • Quotas above what yards can deliver: Wood Mackenzie estimated the old rules would get 26 FPSOs working by 2030, against 36 by 2027 under the new ones.

Sources

  1. CNPE Resolution 7/2017 on local content (Brazil, Ministry of Mines and Energy) (opens in a new tab) April 11, 2017. In Portuguese.
  2. UNCTAD Investment Policy Monitor: Brazil lowered local content requirements for the oil industry (opens in a new tab) April 11, 2017.
  3. Tozzini Freire: Brazil seeks to reduce minimum local content percentages by 50% (opens in a new tab) Law firm newsletter on the February 2017 proposal.
  4. Columbia Center on Sustainable Investment: Local Content, Brazil Petroleum (opens in a new tab) February 2020.
  5. Wood Mackenzie: Impact of Brazil's new local content rules (opens in a new tab) June 20, 2018. Forecasts, not outcomes.
  6. ANP: FPSO Brazil Congress 2026 presentation (opens in a new tab) Brazil's oil regulator. FPSO and module certificates, royalty incentive estimate.
  7. IBGE: In 2 years, shipbuilding industry loses almost half of personnel employed in Brazil (opens in a new tab) June 21, 2018. Brazil's statistics agency.
  8. BNamericas: Why jobs are growing at Brazilian shipyards (opens in a new tab) Sinaval employment figures.
  9. Datamar News: Federal Government encourages shipbuilding in Brazil (opens in a new tab) November 11, 2025.
  10. Agencia iNFRA: Oil and gas production hits record in 2025, ANP bulletin (opens in a new tab) February 2, 2026. In Portuguese.
  11. OilNOW: Petrobras expanding local content expectations beyond formal mandates (Rystad Energy) (opens in a new tab) March 11, 2026.
  12. World Oil: Seatrium delivers first turnkey FPSO to Petrobras (opens in a new tab) July 16, 2025.
  13. Oxford Energy Forum: The impact and effectiveness of local content policy on oil exploration and production in Brazil (opens in a new tab) Issue 98, 2015.
  14. OECD: Local content requirements and their economic effect on shipbuilding (opens in a new tab) OECD Science, Technology and Industry Policy Papers.
  15. CAPP: Canada's Offshore Oil and Gas Industry (opens in a new tab) April 17, 2026. CAPP is the oil industry's association.
  16. C-NLOER: Benefits plan requirements (opens in a new tab)
  17. C-NLOER: First consideration (opens in a new tab)
  18. Government of Newfoundland and Labrador: Bay du Nord benefits agreement (opens in a new tab) March 3, 2026.

Written with AI tools from the public sources listed above. Spot an error? Email info@bdnsupplierdirectory.ca and we'll fix it.